Subjective Assessment of the Effective Contract Impact in Universities on Improving the Indicators of Lectures` Research Work

Article shows the results of a sociological survey aimed at studying the opinion of the teaching staff on the impact of an effective contract on improving the research work indicators in universities in Russia and Belarus. The survey analyzes foreign and Russian evaluation of academic staff performance. A cross-sectional (single-point) study was the design. The focus of research was the academic staff of educational institutions that went over to an effective contract (Northern State Medical University, Russia) and without the implementation of an effective contract (Tobolsk Pedagogical Institute named after D. I. Mendeleev (branch) the University of Tyumen, Russia; National Institute for Higher Education and Belarusian State Pedagogical University named after Maxim Tank, Belarus), the overall number of respondents is 395. A semi-structured questionnaire created by the National Research University Higher School of Economics was used as a tool for sociological research. The study showed that both study groups are aware of an effective contract purpose and criteria evaluation frequency. Respondents from universities without an effective contract receive information from the Internet and have overestimated expectations of the future income level. Respondents of both groups underlined the importance of determining the greatest weight in calculating incentive payments for publication and grant activity, participation in scientific conferences. When implementing an effective contract, not all lecturers are ready to fulfill the criteria for research work, but they note the positive effect of its implementation on the indicators of scientific activity. In the group of respondents without an effective contract, one third expressed doubts about the significant impact of the implementation of an effective contract on improving the performance of research work. This article will be useful to the management of universities when calculating weighting coefficients according to indicators and criteria for evaluating the activities of the teaching staff for the appointment of incentive payments. An interesting study in the future may be a comparison of subjective assessments obtained in universities without an effective contract, and after its implementation in the same universities.

1. Nikulina I. E. Effektivnyi kontrakt v vuze kak draiver povysheniya kachestva truda nauchno-pedagogicheskikh rabotnikov [Effective Contract at the University as a Driver of Work Quality Improvement of Scientific and Pedagogical Workers]. Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii [Higher Education in Russia], 2018, vol. 27, nr 5, pp. 9–19. (In Russ.).

2. Kalinina I. A. O razrabotke celevyh program po realizacii nauchnogo potenciala nauchno-pedagogicheskih rabotnikov universiteta [Designing Target Programs Aimed at Realization of Research Potential of Research and Pedagogical Staff of the University]. Vestnik REU imeni G. V. Plekhanova [Bulletin of the Plekhanov Russian University of Economics], 2016, nr 3 (87), pp. 37–44. doi 10.21686/2413-2829-2016-3-37-44. (In Russ.).

3. Krajnov G. N. Budet li effect ot effektivnogo kontrakta v sisteme vysshego obrazovanija? [Whether There Will be an Effect from Effective Contract in the System of Higher Education?]. Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii [Higher Education in Russia], 2017, nr 5, pp. 52–58. doi 10.31857/s013216250000680-1. (In Russ.).

4. Postnikov S. N., Andrienko A. V. Effektivnyj kontrakt v vuze: praktika realizacii [Effective Contract in Higher School: the Implementation Practice]. Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii [Higher Education in Russia], 2015, nr 5, pp. 37–45. (In Russ.).

5. Kurbatova M. V., Donova I. V. Effektivnyi kontrakt v vysshem obrazovanii: rezul’taty realizatsii proekta [Effective Contract in Higher Education: Some Results of Project Implementation]. Zhurnal institutsional`nykh issledovanij [Journal of Institutional Studies], 2019, vol. 11, nr 2, pp. 122–145. doi 10.17835/2076-6297.2019.11.2.122-145. (In Russ.).

6. Kozina N. S., Kosareckij S. G., Pinskaja M. A. Uslovija raboty i professional’noe samochuvstvie uchitelej v situacii vvedenija effektivnogo kontrakta [Working Conditions and Professional Well-being of Teachers in the Situation of an Effective Contract Introducing]. Informacionnyj bjulleten’ [Newsletter]. Moscow, HSE University, 2016, 40 p. (In Russ.).

7. Kurbatova M. V., Levin S. N. Effektivnyj kontrakt v sisteme vysshego obrazovanija RF: teoreticheskie podhody i osobennosti institucional’nogo proektirovanija [Effective Contract in Higher Education of the Russian Federation: Theoretical Approaches and Features of Institutional Design]. Zhurnal institutsional`nykh issledovanij [Journal of Institutional Studies], 2013, vol. 5, nr 1, pp. 55–80. (In Russ.).

8. Makovskaja N. V. Effektivnaja kontrakcija v akademicheskoj srede Belarusi [Effective Contracting in Belarus’s Academia]. Belorusskij economicheskij zhurnal [Belarusian Economic Journal], 2019, nr 2, pp. 138–151. (In Russ.).

9. Kak platjat professoram? Global’noe sravnenie system voznagrazhdenija i kontraktov [Paying the Professoriate. A Global Comparison of Compensation and Contracts]. Moscow, The Higher School of Economics Publishing House, 2012, 439 p. (In Russ.).

10. Budushhee vysshego obrazovanija i akademicheskoj professii: strany BRIK I SShA [The Global Future of Higher Education and the Academic Profession: BRIC countries and USA]. Moscow, The Higher School of Economics Publishing House, 2013, 248 p. (In Russ.).

11. Agarwal P. Indian Higher Education: Envisioning the Future. New Delhi, India, Sage, 2009, 524 p. (In Eng.).

12. Altbach P. G. Gigantic Peripheries: India and China in the World Knowledge System. Economic and Political Weekly, 1993, vol. 28, nr 24, pp. 1220–1225. (In Eng.).

13. Levin R. Top of the Class: The Rise of Asia’s Universities. Foreign Affairs, 2010, vol. 89, nr 3, pp. 63–75. doi 10.2307/25680916. (In Eng.).

14. Liu C., Li F. BRIC Key for Sustained Growth. China Daily USA Weekly, 2012, February 3, p. 24. (In Eng.).

15. Evans I.M., Meyer L.H. Motivating the Professoriate: Why Sticks and Carrots are only for Donkeys. Higher Education Management and Policy, OECD Publishing, 2003, vol. 15, nr 3, pp. 151–167. doi 10.1787/hemp-v15-art29-en. (In Eng.).

16. Campbell D. J., Campbell K. M., Chia Ho-Beng. Merit Pay, Performance Appraisal, and Individual Motivation: an Analysis and Alternative. Human resource management, 1998, vol. 37, nr 2, pp. 131–146. doi CCC0090-4848/98/02131-16. (In Eng.).

17. Kasten К. L. Tenure and Merit Pay as Rewards for Research, Teaching, and Service at a Research University. Journal of Higher Education, 1984, vol. 55, nr 4, pp. 500–514. doi 10.2307/1981445. (In Eng.).

18. Kontrakty v akademicheskom mire [Contracts in Academic World]. Moscow, The Higher School of Economics Publishing House, 2011, 392 p. (In Russ.).

19. Kuz’minov Ja. I. Akademicheskoe soobshhestvo i akademicheskie kontrakty: vyzovy i otvety poslednego vremeni [Academic Community and Academic Contracts: Challenges and Answers of Recent Times]. Kontrakty v akademicheskom mire [Contracts in Academic World]. Moscow, The Higher School of Economics Publishing House, 2011, pp. 13–30. (In Russ.).

20. Kuz’minov Ja. I., Migunova D. Ju. Strategii rukovoditelej professional’nyh obrazovatel’nyh organizacij i vuzov: studencheskij kontingent, kadry, ekonomika [Strategies of Heads of Professional Educational Organizations and Universities: Student Contingent, Personnel, Economics]. Informacionnyj bjulleten’ [Newsletter]. Moscow, HSE University, 2016, 68 p. (In Russ.).

21. Effektivnyj kontrakt dlja professionalov social’noj sfery: trendy, potencial, reshenija [An Effective Contract for Professionals in the Social Sphere: Trends, Potential, Solutions]. Ekspertnyj doklad [Expert report]. Moscow, The Higher School of Economics Publishing House, 2017, 141 p. (In Russ.).

22. Andreeva A. R., Popova S. A., Rodina N. V. Vnedrenie effektivnogo kontrakta: rezul’taty issledovanija [Implementation of an Effective Contract: Research Results]. Narodnoe obrazovanie [Public education], 2014, nr 10, pp. 151–157. (In Russ.).

23. Derkachjov P. V., Pinskaja M. A. Vnedrenie effektivnogo kontrakta. Sostojavshiesja i nerealizovannye ozhidanija [Implementation of an Effective Contract. Fulfilled and Unfulfilled Expectations]. Upravlenie shkoloj [School Management], 2014, nr 7/8, pp. 14–28. (In Russ.).

24. Klishevich N. S., Varakina Zh. L., Guseva N. S. Effekt ot effektivnogo kontrakta: analiticheskij obzor [The Effect of an Effective Contract: an Analytical Review]. Filosofija i ekonomika v epohu cifrovoj transformacii: sbornik tezisov dokladov po materialam Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii [Philosophy and Economics in the Era of Digital Transformation: Collection of Articles Based on the Materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference]. Minsk, BSEU, 2020, pp. 15–20. (In Russ.).

25. Abankina I. V., Filatova L. M. Effektivnyj kontrakt: tendencii izmenenija motivacii uchitelej [Effective Contract: Trends in Teachers’ Motivation]. Narodnoe obra zovanie [ P ubl ic educat ion], 2015, n r 7, pp. 98–104. (In Russ.).

26. Derkachjov P. V., Zinov’ev A. K. Byl li uspeshen perehod na effektivnyj kontrakt v organizacijah professional’nogo obrazovanija Moskovskoj oblasti [Was the Transition to the Performance-Based Contract at Vocational Schools in Moscow Region Successful?]. Obrazovatel’naja politika [Educational policy], 2016, nr 3 (73), pp. 85–96. doi 10.1080/10609393.2018.1451190. (In Russ.).

27. Antosik L. V., Shevchenko E. S. Ocenka vlijanija effektivnogo kontrakta na publikacionnuju aktivnost’ prepodavatelej: kejs regional’nogo universiteta [Assessment of the Impact of an Effective Contract. Introduction on the Publication Activity of a University Faculty: The Case of a Regional University]. Voprosy obrazovanija [Educational studies], 2018, nr 3, pp. 247–267. doi 10.17323/1814-9545-2018-3-247-267. (In Russ.).

28. Zaichenko N. A. Problema realistichnosti celej effektivnogo kontrakta v obshhem obrazovanii. [The Problem of Realistic Goals of an Effective Contract in General Education]. XVI Aprel’skaya mezhdunarodnaya nauchnaya konferentsiya po problemam razvitiya ekonomiki i obshchestva [The Sixteenth April International Scientific Conference on the Development of Economics and Society]. Moscow, The Higher School of Economics Publishing House, 2016, pp. 605–615. (In Russ.).

29. Rodina N. V., Popova S. A., Andreeva A. R. Sovremennye praktiki oplaty truda po rezul’tatam v obrazovatel’nyh organizacijah vysshego obrazovanija [Modern Practices of Performance-Based Remuneration in Educational Institutions of Higher Education]. XVI Aprel’skaya mezhdunarodnaya nauchnaya konferentsiya po problemam razvitiya ekonomiki i obshchestva [The Sixteenth April International Scientific Conference on the Development of Economics and Society]. Moscow, The Higher School of Economics Publishing House, 2016, pp. 539–546. (In Russ.).